Gary Lineker: BBC ‘should hold its head in shame’ over shelved Gaza documentary

Former BBC presenter – and hundreds of social media users – call ‘Gaza: Doctors Under Attack’ a film that ‘needs to be seen’

By Dalia Anis

Veteran BBC presenter Gary Lineker said that the British broadcaster “should hold its head in shame” after watching Gaza: Medics Under Fire, a documentary originally commissioned, then dropped by the news corporation.

Speaking after a screening of the film in London on Thursday, the BBC’s former Match of the Day presenter said it was “one of the most important films” he’d seen.

“It really did need to be seen, I think everyone would agree with that,” he added.

The documentary tells the stories of Palestinian doctors and health workers working in Gaza under Israeli bombardment and lays out allegations that the Israeli army systematically targeted hospitals and medical staff in the besieged strip throughout its military campaign.

The BBC announced that it had dropped the film in June after a months-long delay due to impartiality concerns.

“We have come to the conclusion that broadcasting this material risked creating a perception of partiality that would not meet the high standards that the public rightly expect of the BBC,” it said in a statement.

https://x.com/MiddleEastEye/status/1940949759591960824

But many critics said the BBC’s decision was an act of censorship, and that it capitulated to pressure to block a film detailing Israel’s conduct on the besieged Palestinian enclave – actions like targeting health workers and hospitals, which would amount to grave violations of international law.

The film was eventually picked up by Channel 4, where it aired on Wednesday, and Zeteo.


Lineker also said the public broadcaster had “declined” in the past two years during Israel’s war on Gaza.

Read also:
Global Warming and U.S. National Security Diplomacy

“I’ve defended it and defended it against claims that it is partial. It talks about impartiality all the time,” he said.

“The truth is at the moment, at the very top of the BBC, not the BBC all over… we’re seeing it on our phones everyday. The problem is they’re bowing to pressure from the top and this is a worry.”

It isn’t the first time the BBC’s former Match of the Day presenter has slammed the broadcaster for censorship.

Lineker was among 500 prominent figures in the entertainment industry who called on the BBC to restore a documentaryGaza: How to Survive a Warzone, which was aired in November, only to be dropped four days later.

The signatories accused the broadcaster of politically motivated censorship following an intense campaign by pro-Israel groups and rival British media outlets, who alleged the documentary promoted “Hamas propaganda”.

‘Unprecented war crimes’

Gaza: Medics Under Fire, which presents personal accounts of the detention, torture and death of medical workers on the frontline, has sent shockwaves online.

“No sane person could watch Gaza Doctors under Attack and have a shred of respect for the state of Israel,” said one user. 

A British doctor said: “now you understand why they [BBC] didn’t want you to see…the documentary”.

“Britain sends weapons to ‘Israel.’ Britain sends RAF spy planes over Gaza. Britain calls ‘Israel’ an ally” she added in a post on X.


Historian William Dalrymple, said the film “shows the reason why Israel will not let journalists in: the unprecedented war crimes that the IDF commit everyday”.


Others invited viewers of the documentary to demand the BBC explain its partiality claim about the film.

Read also:
Trump Reportedly to ‘Flood’ Iran With Sanctions to Make It Harder For Biden to Revive Nuclear Deal

“The BBC said Gaza: Doctors Under Attack fell below the standards the British public expects of the broadcaster,” said British journalist Hamza M Syed.

“If you watched the documentary tonight on @Channel4  and felt otherwise, you should demand to know how and why the BBC came to that conclusion.”

We remind our readers that publication of articles on our site does not mean that we agree with what is written. Our policy is to publish anything which we consider of interest, so as to assist our readers in forming their opinions. Sometimes we even publish articles with which we totally disagree, since we believe it is important for our readers to be informed on as wide a spectrum of views as possible.